Auto Recall Watch
U.S. public vehicle records

Harley-Davidson SOFT TAIL problems and owner complaints

Explore the records behind recurring owner reports.

Key facts

23 owner complaints analyzed

0 distinct recall campaigns

1,700 mi median reported failure mileage

Scope: 2009 to 2009 model years. Data updated: . 21 complaints include usable failure mileage. View data status.

This selection has limited data. It remains available for lookup but is excluded from search indexing.

Owner-reported patterns

Most common problems

Electrical System is the most frequently named component, appearing in 6 of 23 complaints (26.1%). A complaint can name multiple components.

Recurring terms in complaint narratives
TopicMatching reportsShare of complaints
Fuel system concerns521.7%
Braking behavior417.4%
Electrical and battery issues313.0%

Topic matches use published keyword rules. They describe mentions, including negations or comparisons, and do not confirm a diagnosis. Read the matching rules.

Component breakdown

Number of unique complaints naming each component. Top eight shown.

Electrical System
6
Fuel System, Gasoline
4
Power Train
3
Engine And Engine Cooling
2
Exterior Lighting
2
Service Brakes, Hydraulic
2
Tires
2
Exterior Lighting:Turn Signal
1
Component breakdown data
CategoryCount
Electrical System6
Fuel System, Gasoline4
Power Train3
Engine And Engine Cooling2
Exterior Lighting2
Service Brakes, Hydraulic2
Tires2
Exterior Lighting:Turn Signal1

Electrical System: 6; Fuel System, Gasoline: 4; Power Train: 3; Engine And Engine Cooling: 2; Exterior Lighting: 2; Service Brakes, Hydraulic: 2; Tires: 2; Exterior Lighting:Turn Signal: 1

Reported problems by failure mileage

Complaint counts in mileage bands. These are not failure rates per vehicle or mile.

Under 25,000
21
25,000 to 49,999
0
50,000 to 74,999
0
75,000 to 99,999
0
100,000 to 149,999
0
150,000 and above
0
Reported problems by failure mileage data
CategoryCount
Under 25,00021
25,000 to 49,9990
50,000 to 74,9990
75,000 to 99,9990
100,000 to 149,9990
150,000 and above0

Under 25,000: 21; 25,000 to 49,999: 0; 50,000 to 74,999: 0; 75,000 to 99,999: 0; 100,000 to 149,999: 0; 150,000 and above: 0

Under 25,000 miles has the most reports with usable mileage (21). 2 complaints have missing, zero or invalid mileage.

Complaints over time

Year the complaint was filed, not the vehicle model year or incident year. The snapshot year is partial.

2009
5
2010
12
2011
2
2012
2
2014
2
Complaints over time data
CategoryCount
20095
201012
20112
20122
20142

2009: 5; 2010: 12; 2011: 2; 2012: 2; 2014: 2

Pattern summary

Electrical System leads the component reports. Fuel system concerns appears in 5 complaint narratives. Braking behavior appears in 4 complaint narratives. Electrical and battery issues appears in 3 complaint narratives. Use these patterns to inspect individual reports and prepare questions for a mechanic.

Calculated from recorded counts. An AI narrative has not been published for this selection.

Complaint evidence

Examples provide context, not a representative sample or a verified diagnosis.

Owner report 10326844 · 2010-04-21 (April 21, 2010)

HARLEY DAVIDSON FXSTC SOFTAIL CUSTOM 2009 FUEL CAP LEAK UNDER PRESSURE. WHENEVER FUEL TANK IS FILLED TO AT OR ABOVE THE TAB IN THE TANK FUEL IS COMING OUT UNDER PRESSURE THROUGH THE CAP AND SPRAYING ON THE RIDERS LEG AND RUNNING DOWN THE TANK DRIPPING ONTO THE ENGINE. *TR

Owner-reported narrative. 1,200 miles reported. Look up ODI 10326844 at NHTSA ↗

Owner report 10335962 · 2010-06-12 (June 12, 2010)

WHILE DRIVING MY 2009 FLHSTN SOFTTAIL DELUXE ON A TWO WEEK ROAD TRIP, I EXPERIENCED LEAKAGE FROM THE GAS CAP AFTER FILLING UP WITH GAS APPROXIMATELY 10 TIMES. THIS LEAKAGE CONSISTED OF SEVERAL OUNCES OF GASOLINE RUNNING DOWN THE GAS TANK AND ONTO BOTH MYSELF AND THE HOT ENGINE. THIS REQUIRED ME TO STOP THE BIKE AND CLEAN THE GAS OFF WITH RAGS OR RISK A FIRE. AFTER THE FIRST TIME, I DOUBLE CHECKED AFTER EVERY FILL UP TO ENSURE THAT I HAD TIGHTENED THE GAS CAP PROPERLY, HOWEVER THE LEAKAGE CONTINUED. AFTER THIS OCCURRED APPROXIMATELY TEN TIM…

Owner-reported narrative. 6,200 miles reported. Look up ODI 10335962 at NHTSA ↗

Owner report 10327265 · 2010-04-24 (April 24, 2010)

2009 HARLEY-DAVIDSON FXSTSSE3 HD OEM DUNLOP D407 TIRES SHOWING WEAR AT 5,000 MILES, LOCAL DEALER & EMAIL TO DUNLOP WOULD NOT COVER THEM. LATER, PROVIDED LOCAL DEALER SERVICE MANAGER PRINTED COPIES OF HD BULLETINS & INTERNET COMMENTS FROM HD FORUMS ON PROBLEM AND HE GOT APPROVAL TO REPLACE FRONT TIRE WITH D408 AT NO CHARGE BECAUSE IT HAD SIGNS OF CUPPING. WOULD NOT COVER REAR D407 240/40R18 TIRE EVEN THOUGH AT 6,000 MILES SHOWING EARLY WEAR. DUNLOP WEB SITE ADVERTISES THE D407 & D408 TIRES HAVE MT FOR LONGER LIFE, YET MANY 2008 - 2009 HD…

Owner-reported narrative. 5,000 miles reported. Look up ODI 10327265 at NHTSA ↗

Owner report 10356997 · 2010-09-22 (September 22, 2010)

REAR BRAKE LIGHT SWITCH FAILURE < THAN 8000 MILES (NO BRAKE LIGHTS) HARLEY DAVIDSON KNOWS ABOUT THE PROBLEM BUT WILL NOT FIX. *TR

Owner-reported narrative. 8,000 miles reported. Look up ODI 10356997 at NHTSA ↗

Owner report 10279212 · 2009-08-03 (August 3, 2009)

BATTERY COVER DOES NOT STAY CLOSED DURING THE OPERATION OF THE MOTORCYCLE. THE COVER WILL FALL OPEN WHILE RIDING CAUSING IT TO HIT THE RIDERS LEG. ALTHOUGH THE COVER IT'S SELF DOES NOT WEIGH ENOUGH TO CAUSE INJURY, IT IS A SIGNIFICANT DISTRACTION WHICH COULD RESULT IN THE LOSS OF CONTROL. BOTH BIKES HAVE BEEN TO THE DEALER SEVERAL TIMES FOR REPAIRS, UNFORTUNATELY THE REPAIR PARTS ARE ON BACK ORDER. CONTINUED DIFFICULTY IN GETTING THE COVER TO STAY CLOSED ON THE 08 BIKE CAUSED THE DEALER TO REMOVE THE COVER AS A TEMPORARY FIX UNTIL THE REPAI…

Owner-reported narrative. 1,600 miles reported. Look up ODI 10279212 at NHTSA ↗

Owner report 10279214 · 2009-08-03 (August 3, 2009)

BATTERY COVER DOES NOT STAY CLOSED DURING THE OPERATION OF THE MOTORCYCLE. THE COVER WILL FALL OPEN WHILE RIDING CAUSING IT TO HIT THE RIDERS LEG. ALTHOUGH THE COVER IT'S SELF DOES NOT WEIGH ENOUGH TO CAUSE INJURY, IT IS A SIGNIFCANT DISTRACTION WHICH COULD RESULT IN THE LOSS OF CONTROL. BOTH BIKES HAVE BEEN TO THE DEALER SEVERAL TIMES FOR REPAIRS, UNFORTINATLY THE REPAIR PARTS ARE ON BACK ORDER. CONTINUED DIFFICULTY IN GETTING THE COVER TO STAY CLOSED ON THE 08 BIKE CAUSED THE DEALER TO REMOVE THE COVER AS A TEMPORARY FIX UNTIL THE REPAIR …

Owner-reported narrative. 1,500 miles reported. Look up ODI 10279214 at NHTSA ↗

Compare model years

Recalls by model year

All campaigns in the snapshot affecting each model year, including recalls announced years later.

Recall campaigns

Shared campaigns appear once in each affected model year.

2009
0
Recall campaigns data
CategoryCount
20090

2009: 0

Year-by-year records

Harley-Davidson SOFT TAIL model-year comparison
Model yearComplaintsRecallsChange in recalls
2009230Not available
Explore the data

Vehicle analysis explorer

Inspect model-year patterns, reported mileage, monthly activity and the evidence behind each signal.

Data completeness

23 unique complaints in this selection. Analysis snapshot: 2026-10-01.

91.3%Usable mileage21 / 23 records
100.0%Valid incident date23 / 23 records
100.0%Valid filing date23 / 23 records
100.0%Ordered incident and filing dates23 / 23 records

Missing, zero and invalid mileage is excluded. Dates after the snapshot are excluded. Examples are limited selections, not a representative sample.

Problems by model year

Model-wide comparison of the eight most reported components across the model. Cells show counts and shares within each model year. Open a cell for source examples.

Component complaint heatmap
Component2009
Electrical System
626.1%
ODI 10279212 · 1,600 mi

BATTERY COVER DOES NOT STAY CLOSED DURING THE OPERATION OF THE MOTORCYCLE. THE COVER WILL FALL OPEN WHILE RIDING CAUSING IT TO HIT THE RIDERS LEG. ALTHOUGH THE COVER IT'S SELF DOES NOT WEIGH ENOUGH TO CAUSE INJURY, IT IS A SIGNIFICANT DISTRACTION WHICH COULD RESULT IN THE LOSS OF CONTROL. BOTH BIKES HAVE BEEN TO THE DEALER SEVERAL TIMES FOR REPAIRS, UNFORTUNATELY THE REPAIR PARTS ARE ON BACK ORDER. CONTINUED DIFFICULTY IN GETTING THE COVER TO STAY CLOSED ON THE 08 BIKE CAUSED THE DEALER TO REMOVE THE COVER AS A TEMPORARY FIX UNTIL THE REPAI…

Look up ODI 10279212 at NHTSA ↗

Fuel System, Gasoline
417.4%
ODI 10326844 · 1,200 mi

HARLEY DAVIDSON FXSTC SOFTAIL CUSTOM 2009 FUEL CAP LEAK UNDER PRESSURE. WHENEVER FUEL TANK IS FILLED TO AT OR ABOVE THE TAB IN THE TANK FUEL IS COMING OUT UNDER PRESSURE THROUGH THE CAP AND SPRAYING ON THE RIDERS LEG AND RUNNING DOWN THE TANK DRIPPING ONTO THE ENGINE. *TR

Look up ODI 10326844 at NHTSA ↗

Power Train
313.0%
ODI 10356833 · 1,700 mi

PURCHASED A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON ( NEW ) IN JUNE OF 2010. AT 1700 MILES THE BOLTS THAT HOLD THE REAR SPROCKET TO THE WHEEL HAVE BACKED OUT CAUSING WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN A CATASTROPHIC FAILURE IE: REAR WHEEL LOCKING UP AT A HIGHWAY SPEED AND CAUSING A CRASH. HARLEY DAVIDSON MECHANICS STATED TO ME THIS IS NOT THE FIRST ONE THEY HAVE SEEN. I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT HD HAS NOT INSTITUTED A RECALL, THEY HAVE TO BE AWARE OF PROBLEM THROUGH FEEDBACKS FROM SHOPS. THIS IS NOT SOMETHING TO MESS AROUND WITH, THIS CAN BE LIFE THREATENING, SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE …

Look up ODI 10356833 at NHTSA ↗

Engine And Engine Cooling
28.7%
ODI 10339571

I HAVE A 2009 HARLEYDAVIDSON ULTRA THAT RUNS SO HOT IT IS SOMETIMES UNBEARABLE TO SIT ON AT LONG TRAFFIC LIGHTS. I KNOW THAT IF I HAD SHORTS ON MY RIGHT LEG WOULD GET BURNED,IT IS THAT HOT. I KNOW THAT THIS HEAT HAS TO AFFECT THE LONGEVITY OF THE MOTOR AND AFTER PAYING $20,000 FOR A MOTORCYCLE I DON'T BELIEVE THAT I SHOULD HAVE TO SPEND ANOTHER $2,000 TO TRY TO CORRECT THE PROBLEM WHILE VOIDING THE FACTORY WARRANTY. I ALSO KNOW THAT IT IS AN AIR COOLED MOTOR SINCE I HAVE TWO OTHERS A1986, AND A 1996 BOTH RUN MUCH COOLER THAN THIS 2009. I REMOVE…

Look up ODI 10339571 at NHTSA ↗

Exterior Lighting
28.7%
ODI 10257461 · 2,900 mi

TL*THE CONTACT OWNS A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFT TAIL. WHILE DRIVING 70 MPH, THE CONTACT ACTIVATED THE PASSENGER SIDE TURN SIGNAL AND WAS ALMOST STRUCK BY ANOTHER DRIVER. THE OTHER DRIVER INFORMED HIM THAT THE PASSENGER SIDE SIGNAL DID NOT ILLUMINATE. THE CONTACT CHECKED THE SIGNAL AND NOTICED THAT THE INDICATOR DID NOT ILLUMINATE AND THE SIGNAL LIGHT WAS BLOWN. THE DEALER CONFIRMED THE FAILURES. THE CONTACT FEELS THAT THE DEFECT IS UNSAFE BECAUSE WHEN THE LIGHT BULB IS BLOWN AND THE SIGNAL INDICATOR STILL ILLUMINATES, THERE IS NO WAY TO DE…

Look up ODI 10257461 at NHTSA ↗

Service Brakes, Hydraulic
28.7%
ODI 10356997 · 8,000 mi

REAR BRAKE LIGHT SWITCH FAILURE < THAN 8000 MILES (NO BRAKE LIGHTS) HARLEY DAVIDSON KNOWS ABOUT THE PROBLEM BUT WILL NOT FIX. *TR

Look up ODI 10356997 at NHTSA ↗

Tires
28.7%
ODI 10327265 · 5,000 mi

2009 HARLEY-DAVIDSON FXSTSSE3 HD OEM DUNLOP D407 TIRES SHOWING WEAR AT 5,000 MILES, LOCAL DEALER & EMAIL TO DUNLOP WOULD NOT COVER THEM. LATER, PROVIDED LOCAL DEALER SERVICE MANAGER PRINTED COPIES OF HD BULLETINS & INTERNET COMMENTS FROM HD FORUMS ON PROBLEM AND HE GOT APPROVAL TO REPLACE FRONT TIRE WITH D408 AT NO CHARGE BECAUSE IT HAD SIGNS OF CUPPING. WOULD NOT COVER REAR D407 240/40R18 TIRE EVEN THOUGH AT 6,000 MILES SHOWING EARLY WEAR. DUNLOP WEB SITE ADVERTISES THE D407 & D408 TIRES HAVE MT FOR LONGER LIFE, YET MANY 2008 - 2009 HD…

Look up ODI 10327265 at NHTSA ↗

Exterior Lighting:Turn Signal
14.3%
ODI 10257461 · 2,900 mi

TL*THE CONTACT OWNS A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFT TAIL. WHILE DRIVING 70 MPH, THE CONTACT ACTIVATED THE PASSENGER SIDE TURN SIGNAL AND WAS ALMOST STRUCK BY ANOTHER DRIVER. THE OTHER DRIVER INFORMED HIM THAT THE PASSENGER SIDE SIGNAL DID NOT ILLUMINATE. THE CONTACT CHECKED THE SIGNAL AND NOTICED THAT THE INDICATOR DID NOT ILLUMINATE AND THE SIGNAL LIGHT WAS BLOWN. THE DEALER CONFIRMED THE FAILURES. THE CONTACT FEELS THAT THE DEFECT IS UNSAFE BECAUSE WHEN THE LIGHT BULB IS BLOWN AND THE SIGNAL INDICATOR STILL ILLUMINATES, THERE IS NO WAY TO DE…

Look up ODI 10257461 at NHTSA ↗

Darker cells indicate a larger share of submitted complaints. Components overlap. This measures complaint composition, not failure probability.

Failure mileage by component

Median and middle 50% of usable owner-reported mileages. Ranges require at least five records.

Component failure mileage distribution
ComponentMileage range (25th–75th percentile)MedianUsable recordsExamples
Electrical System1,500–1,750 mi1,600 mi5
ODI 10279212 · 1,600 mi

BATTERY COVER DOES NOT STAY CLOSED DURING THE OPERATION OF THE MOTORCYCLE. THE COVER WILL FALL OPEN WHILE RIDING CAUSING IT TO HIT THE RIDERS LEG. ALTHOUGH THE COVER IT'S SELF DOES NOT WEIGH ENOUGH TO CAUSE INJURY, IT IS A SIGNIFICANT DISTRACTION WHICH COULD RESULT IN THE LOSS OF CONTROL. BOTH BIKES HAVE BEEN TO THE DEALER SEVERAL TIMES FOR REPAIRS, UNFORTUNATELY THE REPAIR PARTS ARE ON BACK ORDER. CONTINUED DIFFICULTY IN GETTING THE COVER TO STAY CLOSED ON THE 08 BIKE CAUSED THE DEALER TO REMOVE THE COVER AS A TEMPORARY FIX UNTIL THE REPAI…

Look up ODI 10279212 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10279214 · 1,500 mi

BATTERY COVER DOES NOT STAY CLOSED DURING THE OPERATION OF THE MOTORCYCLE. THE COVER WILL FALL OPEN WHILE RIDING CAUSING IT TO HIT THE RIDERS LEG. ALTHOUGH THE COVER IT'S SELF DOES NOT WEIGH ENOUGH TO CAUSE INJURY, IT IS A SIGNIFCANT DISTRACTION WHICH COULD RESULT IN THE LOSS OF CONTROL. BOTH BIKES HAVE BEEN TO THE DEALER SEVERAL TIMES FOR REPAIRS, UNFORTINATLY THE REPAIR PARTS ARE ON BACK ORDER. CONTINUED DIFFICULTY IN GETTING THE COVER TO STAY CLOSED ON THE 08 BIKE CAUSED THE DEALER TO REMOVE THE COVER AS A TEMPORARY FIX UNTIL THE REPAIR …

Look up ODI 10279214 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10351105 · 1,100 mi

2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON VRSC V-ROD MUSCLE. HAVE BEEN READING OF NUMEROUS MUSCLES GOING DEAD FROM AN ELECTRICAL ISSUE TO INCLUDE ISSUES WITH GAS GAUGE FAILING. I RECENTLY PURCHASED NEW 2009 MUSCLE APPROXIMATELY 3 MONTHS AGO, AND JUST HAD THIS HAPPEN TO ME TONIGHT. BIKE STARTED AND THEN IMMEDIATELY WENT DEAD AS I STARTED TO PULL AWAY. BIKE HAD TO BE TOWED TO MY HOME AND IS AWAITING DEALERSHIP PICK-UP. THIS CAN BE A VERY DANGEROUS ISSUE AND CAUSE A CRASH, AND AT VERY LEAST LEAVE ONE STRANDED IN A VERY UNSAFE ENVIRONMENT. *TR

Look up ODI 10351105 at NHTSA ↗

Fuel System, GasolineToo few reports for a range1,250 mi4 (sparse)
ODI 10326844 · 1,200 mi

HARLEY DAVIDSON FXSTC SOFTAIL CUSTOM 2009 FUEL CAP LEAK UNDER PRESSURE. WHENEVER FUEL TANK IS FILLED TO AT OR ABOVE THE TAB IN THE TANK FUEL IS COMING OUT UNDER PRESSURE THROUGH THE CAP AND SPRAYING ON THE RIDERS LEG AND RUNNING DOWN THE TANK DRIPPING ONTO THE ENGINE. *TR

Look up ODI 10326844 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10335962 · 6,200 mi

WHILE DRIVING MY 2009 FLHSTN SOFTTAIL DELUXE ON A TWO WEEK ROAD TRIP, I EXPERIENCED LEAKAGE FROM THE GAS CAP AFTER FILLING UP WITH GAS APPROXIMATELY 10 TIMES. THIS LEAKAGE CONSISTED OF SEVERAL OUNCES OF GASOLINE RUNNING DOWN THE GAS TANK AND ONTO BOTH MYSELF AND THE HOT ENGINE. THIS REQUIRED ME TO STOP THE BIKE AND CLEAN THE GAS OFF WITH RAGS OR RISK A FIRE. AFTER THE FIRST TIME, I DOUBLE CHECKED AFTER EVERY FILL UP TO ENSURE THAT I HAD TIGHTENED THE GAS CAP PROPERLY, HOWEVER THE LEAKAGE CONTINUED. AFTER THIS OCCURRED APPROXIMATELY TEN TIM…

Look up ODI 10335962 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10352644 · 1,200 mi

2009 HARLEY DELUXE GAS CAP UNDER PRESSURE SPRAYS FUEL ONTO THE GAS TANK ENGINE AND RIDER. IF BIKE IS TIPPED ON ITS SIDE GAS LEAKS FROM GAS CAP. WE TOOK THIS TO A DEALER FOR THIS PROBLEM PREVIOUSLY. PROBLEM STILL EXIST. WE WILL TAKE IT BACK TOMORROW. THIS IS A MAJOR SAFETY ISSUE. *TR

Look up ODI 10352644 at NHTSA ↗

Power TrainToo few reports for a range1,700 mi3 (sparse)
ODI 10356833 · 1,700 mi

PURCHASED A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON ( NEW ) IN JUNE OF 2010. AT 1700 MILES THE BOLTS THAT HOLD THE REAR SPROCKET TO THE WHEEL HAVE BACKED OUT CAUSING WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN A CATASTROPHIC FAILURE IE: REAR WHEEL LOCKING UP AT A HIGHWAY SPEED AND CAUSING A CRASH. HARLEY DAVIDSON MECHANICS STATED TO ME THIS IS NOT THE FIRST ONE THEY HAVE SEEN. I CANNOT BELIEVE THAT HD HAS NOT INSTITUTED A RECALL, THEY HAVE TO BE AWARE OF PROBLEM THROUGH FEEDBACKS FROM SHOPS. THIS IS NOT SOMETHING TO MESS AROUND WITH, THIS CAN BE LIFE THREATENING, SOMETHING NEEDS TO BE …

Look up ODI 10356833 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10362345 · 1,000 mi

HARLEY DAVIDSON 2009 FLHTCU (PLACED HERE AS VEHICLE SECTION ONLY LISTS 5 MODELS AND NOT THIS ONE) AUDIBLE LOUD KNOCK COMING FROM THE PRIMARY CHAIN CASE ON EACH ENGINE STARTUP. KNOCK APPEARS TO ORIGINATE FROM THE COMPENSATOR SPROCKET ASSEMBLY WHICH CUSHIONS THE DRIVE SIDE CRANKSHAFT SPROCKET AND THE PRIMARY DRIVE ASSEMBLY WHEN STRIKING EACH OTHER AT ENGINE STARTUP. MANY COMPENSATOR SPROCKET ASSEMBLIES HAVE BEEN FOUND IN FAILURE MODE AND HAVE BEEN REPLACED WITH A MORE ROBUST UNIT (FACTORY INSTALLED ON 2010 AND LATER MODELS) UNDER WARRANTY…

Look up ODI 10362345 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10451956 · 15,600 mi

CLUTCH LEVER SEEMED FAR TO REACH, TOOK IN FOR INSPECTION AND/OR POSSIBLE ADJUSTMENT. CAME BACK WITH CLUTCH LEVER STICKING OR RATCHETING, NO LONGER SMOOTH TO OPERATE. THIS MADE IT VERY HARD TO OPERATE IN THE FRICTION ZONE NEEDED FOR SLOW OPERATION AND TURNING AROUND. CLUTCH WOULD POP AND JUMP FORWARD ALMOST CAUSING TO FALL OVER MANY TIMES. TOOK IN FOR REPAIR.....LUBED AND GROUND OUT THE INSIDE OF WEAR AREA ON LEVER AND UNIT THAT THE CLUTCH CABLE COMES INTO. WAS TOLD THAT IT WOULD WEAR DOWN IN TIME AND BECOME SMOOTH, THAT THIS IS TYPICAL OF THIS…

Look up ODI 10451956 at NHTSA ↗

Engine And Engine CoolingToo few reports for a range13,250 mi1 (sparse)
ODI 10576540 · 13,250 mi

MOTORCYCLE DIED IN INTERSECTION. WHEN I WENT TO RESTART IT, IT TOOK SEVERAL TRIES AND EACH TIME I TRIED I GOT A GRINDING NOISE. FINALLY STARTED BUT LIGHT HAD ALREADY TURNED AND I WAS IN INTERSECTION PAST RED. THIS HAS BECOME MORE FREQUENT. ONLY HAPPENS WHEN MOTOR IS WARMED UP. STARTER? COMPENSATOR? I HAVE READ ON LINE THE BIKES OF THAT TIME PERIOD HAVE THIS PROBLEM. COULD HAVE BEEN HIT BY A CAR. *TR

Look up ODI 10576540 at NHTSA ↗

Exterior LightingToo few reports for a range2,325 mi2 (sparse)
ODI 10257461 · 2,900 mi

TL*THE CONTACT OWNS A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFT TAIL. WHILE DRIVING 70 MPH, THE CONTACT ACTIVATED THE PASSENGER SIDE TURN SIGNAL AND WAS ALMOST STRUCK BY ANOTHER DRIVER. THE OTHER DRIVER INFORMED HIM THAT THE PASSENGER SIDE SIGNAL DID NOT ILLUMINATE. THE CONTACT CHECKED THE SIGNAL AND NOTICED THAT THE INDICATOR DID NOT ILLUMINATE AND THE SIGNAL LIGHT WAS BLOWN. THE DEALER CONFIRMED THE FAILURES. THE CONTACT FEELS THAT THE DEFECT IS UNSAFE BECAUSE WHEN THE LIGHT BULB IS BLOWN AND THE SIGNAL INDICATOR STILL ILLUMINATES, THERE IS NO WAY TO DE…

Look up ODI 10257461 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10394163 · 1,750 mi

TURN SIGNALS FAIL TO FLASH AFTER THE APPLICATION OF THE SERVICE BRAKES ON HARLEY-DAVIDSON MOTORCYCLE. *TR

Look up ODI 10394163 at NHTSA ↗

Service Brakes, HydraulicToo few reports for a range15,000 mi2 (sparse)
ODI 10356997 · 8,000 mi

REAR BRAKE LIGHT SWITCH FAILURE < THAN 8000 MILES (NO BRAKE LIGHTS) HARLEY DAVIDSON KNOWS ABOUT THE PROBLEM BUT WILL NOT FIX. *TR

Look up ODI 10356997 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10453226 · 22,000 mi

APPLIED THE REAR BRAKE TO STOP, PEDAL WENT ALL THE WAY DOWN, FIRE STARTED BY REAR BRAKE LITE SWITCH BY BRAKE FLUID ON HOT EXHAUST. *TR

Look up ODI 10453226 at NHTSA ↗

TiresToo few reports for a range5,400 mi2 (sparse)
ODI 10327265 · 5,000 mi

2009 HARLEY-DAVIDSON FXSTSSE3 HD OEM DUNLOP D407 TIRES SHOWING WEAR AT 5,000 MILES, LOCAL DEALER & EMAIL TO DUNLOP WOULD NOT COVER THEM. LATER, PROVIDED LOCAL DEALER SERVICE MANAGER PRINTED COPIES OF HD BULLETINS & INTERNET COMMENTS FROM HD FORUMS ON PROBLEM AND HE GOT APPROVAL TO REPLACE FRONT TIRE WITH D408 AT NO CHARGE BECAUSE IT HAD SIGNS OF CUPPING. WOULD NOT COVER REAR D407 240/40R18 TIRE EVEN THOUGH AT 6,000 MILES SHOWING EARLY WEAR. DUNLOP WEB SITE ADVERTISES THE D407 & D408 TIRES HAVE MT FOR LONGER LIFE, YET MANY 2008 - 2009 HD…

Look up ODI 10327265 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10413991 · 5,800 mi

I OWN A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFTAIL CUSTOM FXSTC WITH 5,800 MILES ON IT AND THE FRONT TIRE IS SHOWING NOTABLE CUPPING AND EXCESSIVE WEAR. THIS MODEL OF TIRE DUNLOP D407F IS NO LONGER BEING SOLD AND IS SUPERSEDED BY THE D408F. SERVICE BULLETIN M-1258A COVERS OTHER HARLEY MODELS WITH A SIMILAR TIRE AND ISSUE. SINCE A MOTORCYCLE ONLY HAS TWO WHEELS THE CUPPING AND PREMATURE WEAR ARE A HAZARD THAT NEEDS TO BE ADDRESSED AS A SAFETY CONCERN. REPORTED AS CASE #[XXX] TO HARLEY DAVIDSON. THIS ISSUE IS MENTIONED ON SEVERAL HARLEY DAVIDSON RIDER FORUMS. …

Look up ODI 10413991 at NHTSA ↗

Exterior Lighting:Turn SignalToo few reports for a range2,900 mi1 (sparse)
ODI 10257461 · 2,900 mi

TL*THE CONTACT OWNS A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFT TAIL. WHILE DRIVING 70 MPH, THE CONTACT ACTIVATED THE PASSENGER SIDE TURN SIGNAL AND WAS ALMOST STRUCK BY ANOTHER DRIVER. THE OTHER DRIVER INFORMED HIM THAT THE PASSENGER SIDE SIGNAL DID NOT ILLUMINATE. THE CONTACT CHECKED THE SIGNAL AND NOTICED THAT THE INDICATOR DID NOT ILLUMINATE AND THE SIGNAL LIGHT WAS BLOWN. THE DEALER CONFIRMED THE FAILURES. THE CONTACT FEELS THAT THE DEFECT IS UNSAFE BECAUSE WHEN THE LIGHT BULB IS BLOWN AND THE SIGNAL INDICATOR STILL ILLUMINATES, THERE IS NO WAY TO DE…

Look up ODI 10257461 at NHTSA ↗

Complaint and recall timeline

Explore monthly filing activity alongside recall announcements. Up to ten years of monthly history is available.

1 reports2024-112026-10

Solid line: filed complaints. Dashed amber lines: recall announcement dates for this vehicle selection; markers include all recall components. The latest month is partial. Temporal proximity does not establish causation.

Monthly counts, recall campaigns and complaint examples
Monthly complaint and recall timeline
MonthComplaintsCampaigns announcedExamples
2024-110None

No examples available for this selection.

2024-120None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-010None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-020None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-030None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-040None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-050None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-060None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-070None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-080None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-090None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-100None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-110None

No examples available for this selection.

2025-120None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-010None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-020None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-030None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-040None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-050None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-060None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-070None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-080None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-090None

No examples available for this selection.

2026-10 (partial)0None

No examples available for this selection.

Emerging complaint spikes

Complete months in the latest six months with at least 10 complaints, at least twice the preceding 12-month average, and at least three square-root deviations above that average.

This is a descriptive screening rule, not a statistical defect finding. Publicity and reporting changes can increase submissions.

No complete months meet the spike thresholds for this selection.

Equal-age model-year comparison

Model-wide cumulative reports during the first three or five calendar years, starting with the model year (age 0). Only fully elapsed windows are compared.

Age 0Age 1Age 221 reports

2009: 21 complaints

Equal observation windows
Model yearThrough age 0Through age 1Through age 2
200981821
Date coverage across each selected cohort
Date basis for all complaints in selected model years
YearIncident dates usedFiling date fallbacksExcluded dates
20092300

Incident date is preferred when valid and no later than filing; otherwise filing date is used. Model year approximates age. Equal observation time does not adjust for sales, distance driven or reporting delays. One complaint linked to multiple model years can appear in each cohort.

Components reported together

Each cell counts unique complaints naming both components. Open a nonzero cell for examples.

Component co-occurrence matrix
ComponentElectrical SystemFuel System, GasolinePower TrainEngine And Engine CoolingExterior LightingService Brakes, HydraulicTiresExterior Lighting:Turn Signal
Electrical System—000
1
ODI 10394163 · 1,750 mi

TURN SIGNALS FAIL TO FLASH AFTER THE APPLICATION OF THE SERVICE BRAKES ON HARLEY-DAVIDSON MOTORCYCLE. *TR

Look up ODI 10394163 at NHTSA ↗

1
ODI 10356997 · 8,000 mi

REAR BRAKE LIGHT SWITCH FAILURE < THAN 8000 MILES (NO BRAKE LIGHTS) HARLEY DAVIDSON KNOWS ABOUT THE PROBLEM BUT WILL NOT FIX. *TR

Look up ODI 10356997 at NHTSA ↗

00
Fuel System, Gasoline0—000000
Power Train00—00000
Engine And Engine Cooling000—0000
Exterior Lighting
1
ODI 10394163 · 1,750 mi

TURN SIGNALS FAIL TO FLASH AFTER THE APPLICATION OF THE SERVICE BRAKES ON HARLEY-DAVIDSON MOTORCYCLE. *TR

Look up ODI 10394163 at NHTSA ↗

000—00
1
ODI 10257461 · 2,900 mi

TL*THE CONTACT OWNS A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFT TAIL. WHILE DRIVING 70 MPH, THE CONTACT ACTIVATED THE PASSENGER SIDE TURN SIGNAL AND WAS ALMOST STRUCK BY ANOTHER DRIVER. THE OTHER DRIVER INFORMED HIM THAT THE PASSENGER SIDE SIGNAL DID NOT ILLUMINATE. THE CONTACT CHECKED THE SIGNAL AND NOTICED THAT THE INDICATOR DID NOT ILLUMINATE AND THE SIGNAL LIGHT WAS BLOWN. THE DEALER CONFIRMED THE FAILURES. THE CONTACT FEELS THAT THE DEFECT IS UNSAFE BECAUSE WHEN THE LIGHT BULB IS BLOWN AND THE SIGNAL INDICATOR STILL ILLUMINATES, THERE IS NO WAY TO DE…

Look up ODI 10257461 at NHTSA ↗

Service Brakes, Hydraulic
1
ODI 10356997 · 8,000 mi

REAR BRAKE LIGHT SWITCH FAILURE < THAN 8000 MILES (NO BRAKE LIGHTS) HARLEY DAVIDSON KNOWS ABOUT THE PROBLEM BUT WILL NOT FIX. *TR

Look up ODI 10356997 at NHTSA ↗

0000—00
Tires000000—0
Exterior Lighting:Turn Signal0000
1
ODI 10257461 · 2,900 mi

TL*THE CONTACT OWNS A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON SOFT TAIL. WHILE DRIVING 70 MPH, THE CONTACT ACTIVATED THE PASSENGER SIDE TURN SIGNAL AND WAS ALMOST STRUCK BY ANOTHER DRIVER. THE OTHER DRIVER INFORMED HIM THAT THE PASSENGER SIDE SIGNAL DID NOT ILLUMINATE. THE CONTACT CHECKED THE SIGNAL AND NOTICED THAT THE INDICATOR DID NOT ILLUMINATE AND THE SIGNAL LIGHT WAS BLOWN. THE DEALER CONFIRMED THE FAILURES. THE CONTACT FEELS THAT THE DEFECT IS UNSAFE BECAUSE WHEN THE LIGHT BULB IS BLOWN AND THE SIGNAL INDICATOR STILL ILLUMINATES, THERE IS NO WAY TO DE…

Look up ODI 10257461 at NHTSA ↗

00—

Co-reporting does not establish that one component caused another concern.

Recurring narrative patterns

Specific keyword mentions beyond broad component labels. Matching includes negations and comparisons and does not confirm a diagnosis.

2 patterns with matching reports.

Fuel smell or leak mentions

2 mentions · 8.7% of complaints

Median mileage: 1,838 mi (2 usable records).

ODI 10352644 · 1,200 mi

2009 HARLEY DELUXE GAS CAP UNDER PRESSURE SPRAYS FUEL ONTO THE GAS TANK ENGINE AND RIDER. IF BIKE IS TIPPED ON ITS SIDE GAS LEAKS FROM GAS CAP. WE TOOK THIS TO A DEALER FOR THIS PROBLEM PREVIOUSLY. PROBLEM STILL EXIST. WE WILL TAKE IT BACK TOMORROW. THIS IS A MAJOR SAFETY ISSUE. *TR

Look up ODI 10352644 at NHTSA ↗

ODI 10631411 · 2,476 mi

WHILE GETTING OFF OF THE BIKE PASSENGER NOTICED FUEL LEAKING FROM THE FUEL LINE AT THE GAS TANK CONNECTION. UPON CLOSER INSPECTION FOUND THAT THE QUICK CONNECT FITTING AT THE FUEL TANK WAS LEAKING.UPON CLOSER INSPECTION OF THE QUICK CONNECT IT APPEARS TO HAVE TWO INTERNAL "O" RINGS. PRIOR TO THIS ISSUE I HAVE NEVER DISCONNECTED THE FUEL LINE, BIKE HAS NEVER BEEN DROPPED AND THERE HAS BEEN NO OTHER ADVERSE EVENTS TO THIS AREA. WITH THE EXTREMELY LOW MILEAGE (LESS THAN 3,000), METICULOUS CARE AND RUNNING THE FUEL TANK DRY BEFORE STORAGE THERE SHO…

Look up ODI 10631411 at NHTSA ↗

Matching rule\b(fuel leak\w*|gas leak\w*|gas(?:oline)? smell|smell\w* (?:of )?(?:fuel|gas))\b

Warning lights and dashboard alerts

1 mentions · 4.3% of complaints

Median mileage: Unavailable (0 usable records).

ODI 10346011

I HAVE A 2009 HARLEY DAVIDSON STREET GLIDE,BACKED OUT OF GARAGE STARTED ENGINE, AND THEN CHECK ENGINE LIGHT CAME ON AND HAD NO THROTTLE, BUT IDLES, FLY-BY-WIRE THROTTLE,SHUT OFF AND RESTARTED A COUPLE TIMES IT STARTED WORKING PROPERLY, STARTED OUT ON TWO DAY TRIP, ABOUT 30 MILES ON FOUR LANE UP HILL CHECK ENGINE LIGHT CAME ON AND NO THROTTLE BUT HAD IDLE, HAD TO COAST OFF ROAD, UNPLUGGED COMPUTER AND PLUGGED BACK IN AND WENT ON OUR TRIP, RAN OK TO DESTINATION, AFTER STOP AT MOTEL AND EAT SUPPER IT HAPPENED AGAIN,CHECK ENGINE LIGHT ON AND NO THR…

Look up ODI 10346011 at NHTSA ↗

Matching rule\b(warning light\w*|check engine|dashboard warning\w*|malfunction indicator)\b